Controllers question official explanation for US air traffic control outage

Markus Mainka / Shutterstock

Air traffic controllers and a former senior accident investigator are questioning the US government’s explanation for the November 13, 2026, communications failure that halted departures across the country for more than four hours.

Four days after the disruption, the controllers’ union says the FAA has yet to brief its workforce on the specific cause of the outage, and controllers say they want answers.

The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) said it has traced the disruption to excessive data flooding its telecommunications network after contractor L3Harris installed a router at a remote radio site in El Dorado, Arkansas. A second router in Amarillo, Texas, also contributed to the instability, the agency said. Investigators are still determining why the problem spread to communications and radar feeds at 17 of its 22 en route control centers.

Gregory Feith, a former senior air safety investigator with the US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB), questioned how the network could be vulnerable to such a widespread outage from a single computer router.

“Why is the air traffic control system vulnerable to a single-point failure? That doesn’t make any sense,” he told Denver television station 9NEWS.

Feith also challenged Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy’s emphasis on aging equipment and the transition from copper wiring to fiber-optic lines. He said modernization work had been underway for years and questioned why the existing network suddenly became unstable during Friday’s installation.

“Having one router as a single point failure just is baffling to me, and I think a lot of other people in aviation only because we certify aircraft never to have a single-point failure,” Feith said.

Controllers had begun expressing doubts about the official explanation on the night of the outage as well. Washington Examiner reporter Anna Giaritelli told CNN’s Laura Coates that she had contacted 60 controllers about Duffy’s initial explanation.

“None of them are buying what he said,” Giaritelli said. She also questioned why the router work took place during a busy Friday afternoon.

The FAA says maintenance at major control facilities generally takes place at night, but routine replacements at remote sites have been performed during the day for decades without similar disruption. The agency says it will reconsider that practice.

By November 17, controllers were still seeking an internal explanation for what caused the outage. A National Air Traffic Controllers Association spokesperson confirmed to Forbes that the workforce had not been briefed on the specifics of the cause. Three controllers at different facilities told the publication they had received no briefing from supervisors, with one supervisor expressing concern about being held responsible for equipment whose reliability he could not assess.

The router manufacturer has also pushed back against suggestions its equipment failed. Hewlett Packard Enterprise, which owns Juniper Networks, said the device operated as configured by the installer. The FAA has paused further Juniper installations and disabled a broadcasting function on more than 60 other routers while the investigation continues.

Asked on ABC on November 15 how a problem at one remote location could affect the wider network, Duffy acknowledged that investigators were still working on that question.

“We didn’t think that should or would happen,” he said.

The unanswered questions come amid a succession of technology failures that have caused widespread disruptions. A Microsoft global outage began November 12, disrupting Outlook, Teams and other services. HR and payroll provider Workday experienced an outage the following day. On November 16, JPMorgan Chase and other US banks suffered transaction delays and United Airlines delayed departures when pilots could not obtain final aircraft weights due to a computer problem.

The National Security Agency (NSA) and Apple reported further problems on November 17. The NSA attributed disruption to internal systems to scheduled maintenance, while Apple said an internal update had caused outages.

Discussing the broader series of outages on Fox News on November 16, US Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin relayed an unnamed technology contact’s theory that AI programs capable of writing and revising code could overwhelm older systems.

Mullin said the explanation made sense to him, but presented no findings tying it to a particular incident. He also said cybersecurity officials had found no evidence connecting the outages and that he was confident they were unrelated to cyberattacks.

Microsoft has explicitly said its outage was unrelated to AI agents or a cyberattack. FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford likewise said on November 14 that investigators had found “zero evidence of anything AI-related” in the air traffic control failure.

AI-assisted attacks are nevertheless an established concern. A November 13 FBI advisory described hackers using the ARTEX platform to automate intrusions across government, finance and other industries. The advisory covered hacking campaigns underway since at least August 2026, but established no connection to the recent aviation outages.

Exit mobile version