Quantcast
Card image cap

Boeing loses case against Denmark over jet fighter


Boeing had sued the Danish Ministry of Defense after it decided not to disclose the evaluation files regarding the choice of the Lockheed F-35 over the Boeing F-18 Super Hornet. On March 23, 2018, The court of Copenhagen released its verdict: the refusal was legal.

Several voices had emerged in 2016, when Denmark announced its decision of purchasing the Lockheed Martin F-35 Joint Strike Fighter instead of the Eurofighter Typhoon or the Boeing F-18 Super Hornet. Some pointed that of the four criteria that were evaluated (strategic, military, economic and industrial aspects), the economical one was flawed: while the F-35A procurement is priced at only $80 million per plane (a price that should be reached in 2019), the Super Hornet was evaluated at $122 million per plane, way over the official figure ($57 million).

The evaluation also describes the Super Hornet as a “double-seat aircraft” which obviously adds the cost of a weapon systems officer training to the plane operation. However, a single-seat version of the Super Hornet exists, but was apparently not evaluated by Denmark.

The choice of Denmark did not come as a surprise: with its longer operational capability, the F-35 can be bought in smaller numbers, which is something preferred by smaller countries. The need for an aircraft sporting cutting-edge technology to ensure air superiority in case of a Russian engagement, coupled with an equivalent price to the less impressive Eurofighter Typhoon, seems to have been determinant. The fact that Denmark is already participating in the F-35 joint production also played a role.

However, the evaluation was deemed as “over-enthusiast” regarding the F-35 performance, especially since it was done at a time when the plane had scarce amount of engagement data to provide compared to the more battle-proven Super Hornet and Typhoon.

In a statement released the day of the decision, Boeing justified its legal action, saying it was trying „to gain a better understanding of the evaluation process, in which [they] believe the Ministry made a number of critical errors and omissions in its evaluation.”

The Danish Ministry of Defense had initially refused access to the evaluation data as it would be “too complicated” to find every document since the beginning of the negotiations, in 2005. Boeing should not appeal of the Court’s decision.

Similar news
Lockheed makes groundbreaking proposal to Japan
Defense
Lockheed makes groundbreaking proposal to Japan

Lockheed Martin is the first company to answer the tender of the Japan air force for a new air superiority fighter. And...

Sikorsky adds German partners in battle for helicopter tender
Defense
Sikorsky adds German partners in battle for helicopter tender

The German Bundeswehr  started in December 2017 a tender for a new heavy lift helicopter. In an attempt to win the...

F-22 incident hints faulty engine
Defense
F-22 incident hints faulty engine

An F-22 Raptor of the 3rd Air Force Wing reportedly had an incident during takeoff at the air training center NAS Fallon...

Greek fighter crashes amid airspace tensions with Turkey
Defense
Greek fighter crashes amid airspace tensions with Turkey

A Mirage 2000-5 of the 331th Squadron of the Hellenic Air Force crashed in the Aegean Sea, 9 nautical miles north of Sky...

Two Russian pilots die in assault helicopter crash in Baltic Sea
Defense
Two Russian pilots die in assault helicopter crash in Baltic Sea

A KA-29 assault transport helicopter crashed on April 12, 2018, in the Baltic Sea, west of Kaliningrad. The incident hap...

F-35 deliveries suspended by Pentagon
Defense
F-35 deliveries suspended by Pentagon

The deliveries of the F-35 to the U.S. Department of Defense by Lockheed Martin are suspended, according to Reuters. Bot...

Algerian military transporter crashes, 257 dead
Defense
Algerian military transporter crashes, 257 dead

A Ilyushin IL-76 transport plane belonging to Algerian air force has crashed on April 11, 2018 at Boufarik military airp...

Germany to buy four drones from U.S. for $2.5 billion
Defense
Germany to buy four drones from U.S. for $2.5 billion

The Defense Security Cooperation Agency (DCAS) announced an approval of the sale of four MQ-4C Triton drones on April 5,...

Two Franco-German projects at the center of Berlin Air Show
Defense
Two Franco-German projects at the center of Berlin Air Show

Two joint projects between France and Germany should be announced during the ILA Berlin Air Show on April 25, 2018....

Opinion: space race the Pentagon doesn’t want
Defense
Opinion: space race the Pentagon doesn’t want

Well, actually it wants it. Just not a new bureaucracy to run it....