Downed Lion Air B737 MAX 8 in “un-airworthy” condition: report
Indonesian investigators have released the first report into the fatal crash of Lion Air’s Boeing 737 MAX 8. The preliminary findings, based on the data retrieved from the flight data recorder, confirm that the jetliner experienced speed and altitude issues on its previous flights and states it was in an “un-airworthy” condition on the day it crashed. The report also seems to focus onto Lion Air’s safety culture and the pilots’ actions, including the decision to continue flying the malfunctioning aircraft.
The preliminary report into the loss of Lion Air Flight JT610, published by Indonesia’s National Transport Safety Committee (KNKT) on November 28, 2018, revolves around data recovered from the first and so far, the only found ‘black box’, which indicated a malfunction in the Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System (MCAS).
“The Digital Flight Data Recorder (DFDR) recorded a difference between left and right Angle of Attack (AoA) of about 20° and continued until the end of recording. During rotation the left control column stick shaker activated and continued for most of the flight,” the report states. This is despite the fact that prior to its last two flights, the AoA sensor had been replaced and tested.
The MCAS is Boeing’s new anti-stall system, installed on MAX planes. It is activated when angle of attack (AOA) sensors indicate that the airframe is in a dangerously high angle and attempts to correct it by pushing the plane nose down. But if the AOA signal is erroneous, the MCAS can cause an airplane to stall.
The flight data reveals that the aircraft’s systems had detected an imminent stall due to the faulty indicator, causing the “stick-shaker” (which vibrates the aircraft’s steering-wheel and warns the captain) to activate and remain so throughout most of the flight. To prevent a stall, the automated anti-stall system directed the aircraft’s nose down.
The document reveals pilots had repeatedly reported to the Jakarta Air Traffic Control (ATC) the aircraft was experiencing “flight control problem” asking for the aircraft’s altitude as they struggled to steady the plane. Before losing contact, the flight crew had taken manual control to keep the aircraft’s nose up and were successful in counteracting the anti-stall system, but only for a brief time.
Before the final dive, the flight crew asked the controller to “block altitude 3,000 feet above and below” to avoid traffic. They could not determine their altitude due to all instruments showing different readings. The flight crew’s last words in response to controller’s request for an appropriate altitude, were “five thou”.
Faulty system or faulty maintenance?
What investigators really draw attention to in the report is the airspeed and altitude issues the very same aircraft (PK-LQP) experienced during its four previous flights, particularly the one that preceded the day of the crash. During pre-flight check, the Captain of the October 28, 2018, Denpasar-Jakarta flight had discussed with Lion Air’s maintenance on what had been performed on the plane, including the replacement of an AoA sensor.
Similarly to what occurred a day later, the Boeing 737 MAX 8 also ended up being automatically pitched nose down, but the flight crew shut down the MCAS (the anti-stall system) and continued the flight manually, landing “without incident”. That flight recorded “unreliable” airspeed and altitude disagreement warning, and the Aircraft Flight Maintenance Log later revealed a malfunction in the left primary flight display.
Antonov AN-26 military plane crashes in Ukraine, at least 22 dead
An Antonov AN-26 aircraft crashed in the Kharkov region of Ukraine in the late hours of September 25, 2020. At least 22...
Mexico – the leader of aviation recovery in Latin region
6 months ago, Latin America began facing the COVID-19 pandemic which has done a negative impact for the vast majority of...
JetBlue’s transatlantic ops are still on track: perfect timing?
JetBlue teased the tailfin of its first Airbus A321LR that will take the airline's customers over the Atlantic. Desp...
Despite survival warnings, Airbus to stabilize production output
Despite multiple Guillaume Faury’s warnings about deteriorating situation at the company, Airbus has reviewed its...
El Al Airlines opposes 27-year-old owner: suspects deceit?
The Israel flag carrier El Al Airlines revealed that it opposes the purchase of a controlling stake by Eli Rozenberg, a...