Aviation Safety

Fire retardant caused corrosion in firefighting aircraft, NTSB finds

Air tanker drops bright red fire retardant over a smoky forest below
Aero Air

A fire retardant approved for use in US firefighting aircraft caused extensive corrosion during a single fire season, damaging wing structures, control cables, electrical connectors and engines, according to a National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) investigation.

The findings prompted the NTSB on November 17, 2026, to call for stronger US Forest Service testing requirements. Investigators found that the agency’s approval process had failed to adequately assess how the chemical would affect aircraft under actual operating conditions.

The retardant product, Fortress FR-200, manufactured by Fortress North America, was removed from the Forest Service’s approved list in December 2024. But the NTSB said withdrawing it and a related product did not address the shortcomings in the testing process that allowed them to be approved.

Corrosion reached primary wing structure

The investigation involved two firefighting aircraft: a BAe 146-200A operated by Montana-based Neptune Aviation Services and an MD-87 operated by Oregon-based Aero Air, which flies firefighting missions as Erickson Aero Tanker.

Both participated in a 2023 Forest Service trial examining how the newly approved retardant could be used alongside an existing product.

The aircraft initially carried FR-200, which used magnesium chloride as its active retardant salt. Later in the season, they alternated between that product and Phos-Chek MVP-Fx, a phosphate-based retardant manufactured by Perimeter Solutions.

On the MD-87, corrosion penetrated more than half the thickness of a wing-spar doubler, a reinforcement forming part of the wing’s main load-bearing structure.

Aero Air also replaced more than 90 electrical connectors, several control cables and an approximately 44-inch section of a lengthwise structural member in the fuselage. Investigators found corrosion in three engines used on the twin-engine aircraft at different times during the trial.

The BAe 146 showed significant corrosion inside its retardant tank. The trial did not require tanks to be washed between loads of the different products, allowing residual chemicals to mix.

Postseason maintenance revealed the extent of the damage. The Forest Service notified the NTSB in March 2024 and requested an investigation because of the potential for corrosion to lead to an accident.

Earlier tests had raised concerns

Problems had surfaced during a 2021 evaluation of Fortress FR-100, a related magnesium chloride-based product. Operators reported corrosion and deposits when it interacted with existing retardants, and laboratory testing subsequently confirmed incompatibilities.

The NTSB found that reports and feedback from operators and vendors pointed to a need for further testing and revised procedures. Nevertheless, the Forest Service proceeded with the 2023 trial without additional corrosion testing.

The Forest Service had granted FR-200 full approval in December 2022 after laboratory tests and a field evaluation using a single-engine airtanker with a fiberglass retardant tank.

The qualification tests examined individual metal samples but did not adequately represent the combinations of metals, fasteners, joints and assembled structures found in aircraft.

Subsequent testing showed FR-200 could promote corrosion on its own. Mixing it with a phosphate-based retardant could intensify corrosion under some conditions.

NTSB seeks tougher approval requirements

The Forest Service suspended the qualifications of FR-100 and FR-200 in May 2024 before removing them from its approved list that December.

Fortress parent Compass Minerals acknowledged the corrosion findings in March 2024, saying safety took priority and that the products had passed the Forest Service’s prescribed tests.

In March 2025, Compass announced it would wind down Fortress North America as part of a broader cost-cutting program.

The NTSB now wants the Forest Service to work with aircraft corrosion specialists, operators and manufacturers to develop tests that better represent aircraft construction and the effects of mixing retardants. It also recommended incorporating those tests into the agency’s qualification requirements.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *